...because he is not assisted by them on so urgent an occasion, when the enemy were so close at hand, and when [corn] could neither be bought nor taken from the fields, particularly as, in a great measure urged by their prayers, he had undertaken the war; much more bitterly, therefore does he complain of his being forsaken.

17 Then at length Liscus, moved by Caesar's speech, discloses what he had hitherto kept secret:-that there are some whose influences with the people is very great, who, though private men, have more power than the magistrates themselves: that these by seditions and violent language are deterring the populace from contributing the corn which they ought to supply; [by telling them] that, if they can not any longer retain the supremacy of Gaul, it were better to submit to the government of Gauls than of Romans, nor ought they to doubt that, if the Romans should overpower the Helvetii, they would wrest their freedom from the Aedui together with the remainder of Gaul.

...because he is not assisted by them on so urgent an occasion, when the enemy were so close at hand, and when [corn] could neither be bought nor taken from the fields, particularly as, in a great measure urged by their prayers, he had undertaken the war; much more bitterly, therefore does he complain of his being forsaken.

17 Then at length Liscus, moved by Caesar's speech, discloses what he had hitherto kept secret:-that there are some whose influences with the people is very great, who, though private men, have more power than the magistrates themselves: that these by seditions and violent language are deterring the populace from contributing the corn which they ought to supply; [by telling them] that, if they can not any longer retain the supremacy of Gaul, it were better to submit to the government of Gauls than of Romans, nor ought they to doubt that, if the Romans should overpower the Helvetii, they would wrest their freedom from the Aedui together with the remainder of Gaul.

Translated by W. A. McDevitte and W. S. Bohn (1915)
About my VERY Literal Translation Below

Below is my suggestion for a very literal, almost word for word, translation to try and make it easier to understand the Latin. It is not to be regarded as a good English translation and there are bound to be errors and oversights.

My intention is to start a discussion here so that collectively we help each other to learn to read and understand these Latin Classics better.

Please feel free to offer suggestions and improve on my attempt.

Please contribute ideas and questions in the comments below BUT remember to ALWAYS be respectful of others.

About my VERY Literal Translation Below

Below is my suggestion for a very literal, almost word for word, translation to try and make it easier to understand the Latin. It is not to be regarded as a good English translation and there are bound to be errors and oversights.

My intention is to start a discussion here so that collectively we help each other to learn to read and understand these Latin Classics better.

Please feel free to offer suggestions and improve on my attempt.

Please contribute ideas and questions in the comments below BUT remember to ALWAYS be respectful of others.

How To Read the Interactive Text

To Read the Interactive Text Below Without a Dictionary-

On a Computer: you hover over a word and get all the possible parts of speech; declensions; and conjugations of every word. 

How To Read the Interactive Text

To Read the Interactive Text Below Without a Dictionary-

On a Phone or Tablet: Simply 'tap' the word to get the full dictionary definition
To remove the 'definition box' you 'tap' to the side of the text box.

[6] quod, cum neque emi neque ex agris sumi possit,

You Need to be a Member to Access the Interactive Dictionary

Become a Member

tam necessario tempore, tam propinquis hostibus ab iis non sublevetur, praesertim cum magna ex parte eorum precibus adductus bellum susceperit; [multo etiam gravius quod sit destitutus queritur].

CHAPTER 17
Tum demum Liscus oratione Caesaris adductus quod antea tacuerat proponit: esse non nullos, quorum auctoritas apud plebem plurimum valeat, qui privatim plus possint quam ipsi magistratus.

[2] Hos seditiosa atque improba oratione multitudinem deterrere, ne frumentum conferant quod debeant:

[3] praestare, si iam principatum Galliae obtinere non possint, Gallorum quam Romanorum imperia perferre,

[4] neque dubitare [debeant] quin, si Helvetios superaverint Romani, una cum reliqua Gallia Haeduis libertatem sint erepturi.

Get Interactive Dictionary

 

because since (corn) could neither be bought nor taken from the fields,

You Need to be a Member to Access the Literal Translation

Become a Member

because he is not assisted by them on so urgent an occasion, when the enemy were so close at hand, and when [corn] could neither be bought nor taken from the fields, particularly as, in a great measure urged by their prayers, he had undertaken the war; much more bitterly, therefore does he complain of his being forsaken.

17 Then at length Liscus, moved by Caesar's speech, discloses what he had hitherto kept secret:-that there are some whose influences with the people is very great, who, though private men, have more power than the magistrates themselves: that these by seditions and violent language are deterring the populace from contributing the corn which they ought to supply; [by telling them] that, if they can not any longer retain the supremacy of Gaul, it were better to submit to the government of Gauls than of Romans, nor ought they to doubt that, if the Romans should overpower the Helvetii, they would wrest their freedom from the Aedui together with the remainder of Gaul.

Translated by W. A. McDevitte and W. S. Bohn (1915)

quod, cum neque emi neque ex agris sumi possit,

You Need to be a Member to Access the Interactive Dictionary

FIND OUT MORE

because since (corn) could neither be bought nor taken from the fields

You Need to be a Member to Access the Literal Translation

FIND OUT MORE

s2Member®