By these very men, [said he], are our plans and whatever is done in the camp, disclosed to the enemy; that they could not be restrained by him: nay more, he was well aware, that though compelled by necessity, he had disclosed the matter to Caesar, at how great a risk he had done it; and for that reason, he had been silent as long as he could."
18 Caesar perceived that by this speech of Liscus, Dumnorix, the brother of Divitiacus, was indicated; but, as he was unwilling that these matters should be discussed while so many were present, he speedily dismisses: the council, but detains Liscus: he inquires from him when alone, about those things which he had said in the meeting. He [Liscus] speaks more unreservedly and boldly. He [Caesar] makes inquiries on the same points privately of others, and discovered that it is all true; that "Dumnorix is the person, a man of the highest daring, in great favor with the people on account of his liberality, a man eager for a revolution: that for a great many years he has been in the habit of contracting for the customs and all the other taxes of the Aedui at a small cost, because when he bids, no one dares to bid against him.
By these very men, [said he], are our plans and whatever is done in the camp, disclosed to the enemy; that they could not be restrained by him: nay more, he was well aware, that though compelled by necessity, he had disclosed the matter to Caesar, at how great a risk he had done it; and for that reason, he had been silent as long as he could."
18 Caesar perceived that by this speech of Liscus, Dumnorix, the brother of Divitiacus, was indicated; but, as he was unwilling that these matters should be discussed while so many were present, he speedily dismisses: the council, but detains Liscus: he inquires from him when alone, about those things which he had said in the meeting. He [Liscus] speaks more unreservedly and boldly. He [Caesar] makes inquiries on the same points privately of others, and discovered that it is all true; that "Dumnorix is the person, a man of the highest daring, in great favor with the people on account of his liberality, a man eager for a revolution: that for a great many years he has been in the habit of contracting for the customs and all the other taxes of the Aedui at a small cost, because when he bids, no one dares to bid against him.
Translated by W. A. McDevitte and W. S. Bohn (1915)
About my VERY Literal Translation Below
Below is my suggestion for a very literal, almost word for word, translation to try and make it easier to understand the Latin. It is not to be regarded as a good English translation and there are bound to be errors and oversights.
My intention is to start a discussion here so that collectively we help each other to learn to read and understand these Latin Classics better.
Please feel free to offer suggestions and improve on my attempt.
Please contribute ideas and questions in the comments below BUT remember to ALWAYS be respectful of others.
About my VERY Literal Translation Below
Below is my suggestion for a very literal, almost word for word, translation to try and make it easier to understand the Latin. It is not to be regarded as a good English translation and there are bound to be errors and oversights.
My intention is to start a discussion here so that collectively we help each other to learn to read and understand these Latin Classics better.
Please feel free to offer suggestions and improve on my attempt.
Please contribute ideas and questions in the comments below BUT remember to ALWAYS be respectful of others.
How To Read the Interactive Text
To Read the Interactive Text Below Without a Dictionary-
On a Computer: you hover over a word and get all the possible parts of speech; declensions; and conjugations of every word.
How To Read the Interactive Text
To Read the Interactive Text Below Without a Dictionary-
On a Phone or Tablet: Simply 'tap' the word to get the full dictionary definition
To remove the 'definition box' you 'tap' to the side of the text box.
[5] Ab isdem nostra consilia quaeque in castris gerantur hostibus enuntiari; hos a se coerceri non posse.
You Need to be a Member to Access the Interactive Dictionary
[6] Quin etiam, quod necessariam rem coactus Caesari enuntiarit, intellegere sese quanto id cum periculo fecerit, et ob eam causam quam diu potuerit tacuisse.
CAPUT XVIII
Caesar hac oratione Lisci Dumnorigem, Diviciaci fratrem, designari sentiebat, sed, quod pluribus praesentibus eas res iactari nolebat, celeriter concilium dimittit, Liscum retinet.
Quaerit ex solo ea quae in conventu dixerat. Dicit liberius atque audacius. Eadem secreto ab aliis quaerit; reperit esse vera:
ipsum esse Dumnorigem, summa audacia, magna apud plebem propter liberalitatem gratia, cupidum rerum novarum.
Complures annos portoria reliquaque omnia Haeduorum vectigalia parvo pretio redempta habere, propterea quod illo licente contra liceri audeat nemo.
[5] By the same people our plans and everything carried out in the camps were reported to the enemy; he was not able to restrain these men by himself.
You Need to be a Member to Access the Literal Translation
nay more, he was well aware, that though compelled by necessity, he had disclosed the matter to Caesar, at how great a risk he had done it; and for that reason, he had been silent as long as he could."
CHAPTER 18
Caesar perceived that by this speech of Liscus, Dumnorix, the brother of Divitiacus, was indicated; but, as he was unwilling that these matters should be discussed while so many were present, he speedily dismisses: the council, but detains Liscus:
he inquires from him when alone, about those things which he had said in the meeting. He [Liscus] speaks more unreservedly and boldly.
He [Caesar] makes inquiries on the same points privately of others, and discovered that it is all true; that "Dumnorix is the person, a man of the highest daring, in great favor with the people on account of his liberality, a man eager for a revolution:
that for a great many years he has been in the habit of contracting for the customs and all the other taxes of the Aedui at a small cost, because when he bids, no one dares to bid against him.
Translated by W. A. McDevitte and W. S. Bohn (1915)
[5] Ab isdem nostra consilia quaeque in castris gerantur hostibus enuntiari; hos a se coerceri non posse.
You Need to be a Member to Access the Interactive Dictionary
[5] By the same people our plans and everything carried out in the camps were reported to the enemy; he was not able to restrain these men by himself.
You Need to be a Member to Access the Literal Translation
Recent Comments